Upcoming Events

Dublin | History and Heritage

no events match your query!

New Events

Dublin

no events posted in last week

Blog Feeds

Anti-Empire

Anti-Empire

offsite link North Korea Increases Aid to Russia, Mos... Tue Nov 19, 2024 12:29 | Marko Marjanovi?

offsite link Trump Assembles a War Cabinet Sat Nov 16, 2024 10:29 | Marko Marjanovi?

offsite link Slavgrinder Ramps Up Into Overdrive Tue Nov 12, 2024 10:29 | Marko Marjanovi?

offsite link ?Existential? Culling to Continue on Com... Mon Nov 11, 2024 10:28 | Marko Marjanovi?

offsite link US to Deploy Military Contractors to Ukr... Sun Nov 10, 2024 02:37 | Field Empty

Anti-Empire >>

The Saker
A bird's eye view of the vineyard

offsite link Alternative Copy of thesaker.is site is available Thu May 25, 2023 14:38 | Ice-Saker-V6bKu3nz
Alternative site: https://thesaker.si/saker-a... Site was created using the downloads provided Regards Herb

offsite link The Saker blog is now frozen Tue Feb 28, 2023 23:55 | The Saker
Dear friends As I have previously announced, we are now “freezing” the blog.? We are also making archives of the blog available for free download in various formats (see below).?

offsite link What do you make of the Russia and China Partnership? Tue Feb 28, 2023 16:26 | The Saker
by Mr. Allen for the Saker blog Over the last few years, we hear leaders from both Russia and China pronouncing that they have formed a relationship where there are

offsite link Moveable Feast Cafe 2023/02/27 ? Open Thread Mon Feb 27, 2023 19:00 | cafe-uploader
2023/02/27 19:00:02Welcome to the ‘Moveable Feast Cafe’. The ‘Moveable Feast’ is an open thread where readers can post wide ranging observations, articles, rants, off topic and have animate discussions of

offsite link The stage is set for Hybrid World War III Mon Feb 27, 2023 15:50 | The Saker
Pepe Escobar for the Saker blog A powerful feeling rhythms your skin and drums up your soul as you?re immersed in a long walk under persistent snow flurries, pinpointed by

The Saker >>

Lockdown Skeptics

The Daily Sceptic

offsite link Can Science Tell Us the Meaning of Life? Mon Dec 23, 2024 19:54 | Dr David Bell
At Christmas time, Dr David Bell reflects on what has true value in this world, the limits of science to tell us what that is and what a baby in a manger might have to say about it.
The post Can Science Tell Us the Meaning of Life? appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.

offsite link Non-Crime Hate Incidents Surge in Half of Police Forces Despite Government Crackdown Mon Dec 23, 2024 17:46 | Will Jones
The number of?non-crime hate incidents?recorded by police has surged in half of Britain's forces despite attempts by the previous Government to crack down on the practice, official data show.
The post Non-Crime Hate Incidents Surge in Half of Police Forces Despite Government Crackdown appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.

offsite link Reeves?s Simplistic Thinking Spawned This Budget from Hell Mon Dec 23, 2024 15:44 | David Craig
Simplistic linear thinking by Rachel from Accounts and the Treasury spawned this Budget from hell, says David Craig. A systems thinker would have known it would send the economy into a doom loop of recession and decline.
The post Reeves’s Simplistic Thinking Spawned This Budget from Hell appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.

offsite link British Drivers Steering Away From New Cars In Their Droves Mon Dec 23, 2024 13:00 | Sallust
British car-buyers are turning away from new vehicles in their droves and keeping their reliable old petrol models going for far longer as Labour's Net Zero war on affordable motors heats up.
The post British Drivers Steering Away From New Cars In Their Droves appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.

offsite link Britain on Brink of Recession After Growth Revised to Zero Following Reeves?s Horror Budget Mon Dec 23, 2024 11:09 | Will Jones
Britain is on the brink of a recession after official figures were revised to show zero growth in the third quarter of the year and living standards fell, with Rachel Reeves's horror Budget blamed.
The post Britain on Brink of Recession After Growth Revised to Zero Following Reeves’s Horror Budget appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.

Lockdown Skeptics >>

Voltaire Network
Voltaire, international edition

offsite link Voltaire, International Newsletter N?113 Fri Dec 20, 2024 10:42 | en

offsite link Pentagon could create a second Kurdish state Fri Dec 20, 2024 10:31 | en

offsite link How Washington and Ankara Changed the Regime in Damascus , by Thierry Meyssan Tue Dec 17, 2024 06:58 | en

offsite link Statement by President Bashar al-Assad on the Circumstances Leading to his Depar... Mon Dec 16, 2024 13:26 | en

offsite link Voltaire, International Newsletter N?112 Fri Dec 13, 2024 15:34 | en

Voltaire Network >>

Reply to Anthony Coughlan on CPI book

category dublin | history and heritage | opinion/analysis author Wednesday February 20, 2013 10:07author by Matt Treacy Report this post to the editors

Regarding Anthony Coughlan’s latest attempt to denigrate my books.

The books stand on their merits and I have no need to repeat what is in them. They stand or fall on their own merits. However a number of points in Coughlan’s ‘review’ do need to be addressed.

First of all, the production issues relate to a small number of books sold at the time of the launch. All of these have been corrected and the index is now fully accurate.

He claims the book is ‘thoroughly nasty’. I take it that is a reference to it’s critical analysis of the pro-Soviet Communist movement. I make no more apology for being anti-Stalinist than I do for being anti-Nazi. It is also clear that one of the features of the CP book most upsetting to the inheritors of Irish Stalinism is its exposé of the dishonesty and intellectual gymnastics that were employed to justify the Stalin/Hitler Pact between 1939 and 1941.

A Pact broken, not by the Stalinists but by the Nazis. The same applied to their dogged defence of Soviet foreign policy over the entire period up to the collapse of the USSR.

Contrary to Coughlan’s claim, the book is almost entirely based on original records, including those of the CP itself, and certainly does not rely on ‘Government Ministers’ ‘MI5’, the ‘Catholic Standard’ or fascists for its analysis of Communism during the period under review. The historical is quite clear in regard to the horrors visited on the world by Stalinism and its off-shoots.

It is also clear that Communist Party policy during the period under review was first and foremost a function of Soviet foreign policy. Ample eveidence, some of it quoted in the book, exists to prove Soviet interest in opposing British membership of the EEC, including substantial funding for the CPGB campaign.

That is not to deny that there were genuine reasons for opposing the EEC and Irish republicans were the first to do so. That was a significant factor in persuading the Irish Communists to alter their attitude towards the republican movement after Lemass had applied for membership. That was during the 1956-1962 IRA ‘border campaign’ which the Communists had resolutely opposed and had been disparaging of the republicans until the EEC application once again made them an attractive ‘ally’. All of that is dealt with in both books.

In relation to Greaves, the record clearly shows that he was a member of the CPGB International Department and it was in that capacity that he ran the Connolly Association, and attempted, with a degree of success to influence political events in Ireland through those who shared his position, and indeed his membership of the Communist Party, either in Britain and/or in Ireland.
The evidence for CPGB control of the CA is extensive and conclusive and is dealt with in the book. Indeed, one of the key debates within the CA during the 1950s – extensively dealt with in the book from CPGB sources – was whether the Association ought to have ‘come out’ as the London Irish branch of the CPGB, or remained, as favoured by Greaves and the CPGB International Department, a covertly controlled Party front organisation.

There was also clearly an intention to create a formal alliance between the republican movement and the Irish Communist movement through a National Liberation Front. That was a contributory factor in the split, and the attempt to maintain that alliance continued after the split with formal and high level contacts between the Official republican leadership and the re-unified CPI. That foundered in the mid 1970s due to a combination of factors that will be dealt with in the second volume.

It is also the case that both Coughlan and Roy Johnston were paid up members of the Irish Workers Party at the same time that Johnston was a member of the IRA Army Council and Coughlan was a leading advisor to Cathal Goulding. Indeed Coughlan might well have become more formally involved, had it not been for a January 1966 Ard Comhairle motion proposed by Tom Mitchell which excluded Coughlan from the Sinn Féin/IRA education department on the grounds that the republican constitution banned members of Communist organisations. That again is a matter of record.

The membership lists in the CPI archives are conclusive. They are clearly IWP membership lists and not as disingenuously claimed, subscription lists for the Party bulletin. I believe that this issue has been put to bed. One of those lists is available on several internet forums and of course the other lists are in the CP archive itself.

I do not need a motive to record historical facts! Indeed the implication of the attacks on me is that I ought to have pretended that the lists did not exist at all. The overlapping membership of key individuals is, however, important and opens up different interpretations of what happened within the republican movement in the 1960s. The evidence is there. People may interpret it as they wish. Some, however, prefer to engage in disingenuous ad hominen attacks on myself rather than engage with the facts.

Finally, I again note Coughlan’s promise to deposit the Greaves journals in a public archive. He has had them for a long time now and, unedited, they would be a valuable contribution to the historical record. Until now, we only have Roy Johnston’s extensive use of extracts to thank for what is clearly a unique insight into the period under review.

Prior discussion at: http://www.indymedia.ie/article/102794

 #   Title   Author   Date 
   In answer to Matt Treacy.     Bill OBrien    Thu Feb 21, 2013 20:18 
   Comparing Soviets to Nazis is "thoroughly nasty."     An Drighneán Donn    Fri Feb 22, 2013 12:43 
   bill     james moore    Fri Feb 22, 2013 18:50 
   To An Drighneán Donn     Bobby    Sat Feb 23, 2013 11:15 
   James this is more     Bill OBrien    Sat Feb 23, 2013 12:56 
   The Right Wing love to try to compare Stalin to Hitler     An Drighneán Donn    Sat Feb 23, 2013 13:37 
   bill     james moore    Sat Feb 23, 2013 15:13 
   James     Bill OBrien    Sat Feb 23, 2013 20:48 
   bill     james moore    Sat Feb 23, 2013 21:49 
 10   Reply to Bill     Matt Treacy    Mon Feb 25, 2013 10:28 
 11   Dear Matt     Bill OBrien    Mon Feb 25, 2013 13:09 
 12   Bill     Matt Treacy    Mon Feb 25, 2013 15:39 
 13   Matt come clean     Bill OBrien    Tue Feb 26, 2013 08:38 
 14   The bloody hands of Stalinism     Felix Quigley    Tue Feb 26, 2013 09:12 
 15   Felix     Matt Treacy    Tue Feb 26, 2013 09:49 
 16   No platform     joe mc    Tue Feb 26, 2013 13:23 
 17   Matt Tracy's Right Wing Instinct     An Drighneán Donn    Tue Feb 26, 2013 14:41 
 18   More silliness     Matt Treacy    Tue Feb 26, 2013 14:53 
 19   Matt Tracy Cannot Fail to Reveal Himself     An Drighneán Donn    Tue Feb 26, 2013 15:31 
 20   no debate and Joe Stalin     Gearoid O Loingsigh    Tue Feb 26, 2013 16:20 
 21   The Red Army Defeated the Nazis     An Drighneán Donn    Tue Feb 26, 2013 17:51 
 22   Like all great scumbag leaders, Stalin cowered in the rear while sending millions of young men carelessly to their deaths     fred    Tue Feb 26, 2013 19:26 
 23   Yes, the Red Army won the war     An Drighneán Donn    Tue Feb 26, 2013 19:45 
 24   Gearóid     Matt Treacy    Tue Feb 26, 2013 20:43 
 25   calling the war what it was     Gearoid O Loingsigh    Tue Feb 26, 2013 22:31 
 26   when Matt     Bill OBrien    Tue Feb 26, 2013 22:35 
 27   Don't Worry Matt     An Drighneán Donn    Tue Feb 26, 2013 22:58 
 28   Gearóid when faced with Nazi Power     An Drighneán Donn    Tue Feb 26, 2013 23:22 
 29   Gearóid     Matt Treacy    Wed Feb 27, 2013 08:12 
 30   Your book is most timely     Felix Quigley    Wed Feb 27, 2013 08:35 
 31   Good News for Matt     An Drighneán Donn    Wed Feb 27, 2013 20:05 
 32   Poor ADD     Matt Treacy    Wed Feb 27, 2013 20:35 
 33   get into the present     Bill OBrien    Thu Feb 28, 2013 08:14 
 34   'The Present'     Matt Treacy    Thu Feb 28, 2013 09:28 
 35   I love it when Communism is slandered     An Drighneán Donn    Thu Feb 28, 2013 13:20 
 36   Issues are too serious to be allowed confusion     Felix Quigley    Thu Feb 28, 2013 13:51 
 37   Felix the Critic     An Drighneán Donn    Thu Feb 28, 2013 16:39 
 38   most leaders are just egotistical sociopaths / psychopaths     fred    Thu Feb 28, 2013 21:35 
 39   Fred     An Drighneán Donn    Fri Mar 01, 2013 00:06 
 40   Deflection as an art form     Felix Quigley    Fri Mar 01, 2013 08:44 
 41   For Felix     An Drighneán Donn    Fri Mar 01, 2013 12:35 
 42   ADD     Matt Treacy    Sat Mar 02, 2013 22:00 
 43   Events of 1939     An Drighneán Donn    Sun Mar 03, 2013 01:58 
 44   Irish workers WILL learn about the crimes of the Stalinists!     Felix Quigley    Sun Mar 03, 2013 08:37 
 45   Felix and his bourgeois morality     An Drighneán Donn    Sun Mar 03, 2013 13:35 
 46   100 years after the Dublin Lockout Irish workers need Trotskyism     Felix Quigley    Mon Mar 04, 2013 09:13 
 47   Question for Felix     An Drighneán Donn    Mon Mar 04, 2013 18:39 
 48   I have made my point on Spain     Felix Quigley    Tue Mar 05, 2013 07:46 


Number of comments per page
  
 
© 2001-2024 Independent Media Centre Ireland. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Independent Media Centre Ireland. Disclaimer | Privacy